Back to Calendar

5 Killer Grilled Cheese Recipes

Luckily for you, The Starr Conspiracy’s Fort Worth location hosts a Grilled Cheese Potluck every now and then. We guarantee you’ll never think of the lowly grilled cheese sandwich the same way after you’ve tried these unique variations. For each one, you only need to decide the ratio of one ingredient to the others to tickle your particular fancy.

To perfectly grill your grilled cheese sandwich, our staff of in-house experts recommends this method:

  1. Butter two slices of bread on both sides and brown both slices on one side.
  2. Flip them both over, so the browned sides are now facing up.
  3. While the other sides are browning, add your cheese and other ingredients to one piece, close your sandwich by placing the other piece on top, and enjoy.

You get more butter, more sealed-in flavor, and the perfect light crunch.

Bread Sharp Cheddar Cheese Havarti Cheese Mac ’N’ Cheese Sliced Avocado Bread
Mac ’n’ Cheese Grilled Cheese

Sharp cheddar cheese, Havarti cheese, Mac ’n’ cheese, Sliced avocado

Bread Goat Cheese Sliced Pear Fig Butter Bread
Goat Cheese Grilled Cheese

Goat cheese, Sliced pear, Fig butter

Bread Jarlsberg Cheese Sliced Pear Crispy Bacon Bread
Pear and Bacon Grilled Cheese

Jarlsberg cheese, Sliced pear, Crispy bacon

Bread Mild Cheddar Cheese Mozzarella Cheese and Avocado Bacon Bread
Bacon-cado Grilled Cheese

Mild cheddar cheese, Mozzarella cheese, Sliced avocado, Bacon

Bread Chipotle-and-avocado Mash Oaxaca Cheese Papalo Leaves Bread
Cemita Grilled Cheese

Chipotle-and-avocado mash (recipe below), Oaxaca cheese (grated), Papalo leaves (or cilantro)

Chipotle-and-avocado mash
Combine and mash 1 finely chopped canned chipotle pepper in adobo sauce, 2 teaspoons of the adobo sauce, and 1/2 avocado